Article related image

The Sweet Origins of 5 Popular Pies, From Apple to Pumpkin

For centuries, pie was the closest thing you could find to food storage. Back then, pie crust wasn’t a flaky, buttery delicacy. It was an inedible container — a bready vessel that prevented spoilage and preserved the precious fillings buried inside. A well-baked pie, made with a thick crust called a “coffin,” could last in your pantry for up to a year.

As a result, the earliest pies were valued by anybody who needed to store food for the long haul. Pies were especially beloved by sailors, who required stockpiles of well-preserved food that would take up little space in the bowels of a ship. As the BBC notes, “having a hold stacked with pies was a far more sensible use of precious square metres than bringing a cook and dozen of livestock along for the journey.”

Before the 16th century, most of these pies were filled with savory odds-and-ends. The sweet pies we enjoy today were rare and expensive, reserved for royalty and anybody willing to pay top-dollar for sweeteners. Dessert pies wouldn’t become common among regular diners until the height of the slave trade, which saw millions of sacks of sugar imported from the West Indies.

A Pie by Any Other Name

A slice of cherry pie on a white plate with fork
Credit: alexandermils/ Unsplash

Like the traveling pies of the Middle Ages, the word “pie” itself has taken a fascinating journey. According to the Oxford English Dictionary, the word may be a nod to the magpie, a black-and-white bird common to Europe. It’s believed that early pies, with their light crusts and dark fillings, resembled the bird’s plumage.

Another theory is that the word refers to the magpie’s nest, which is famous for being stuffed with anything the bird can get its claws on. (Early pies, after all, were a motley mix of whatever the cook could find in the kitchen: meat, offal, fruits, spices, and more.) Support for this etymology lies in Scotland’s national dish of haggis, which — like early pies — is famed for containing a slew of ingredients. According to Alison Richards at NPR, “the word haggis or haggesse turns out to be an alternative name for magpie.”

In any case, pie as we know and define it now was in common rotation by the 19th century. Today it's a staple of American cuisine, in particular, and the preferred dessert for many holidays. Home cooks and professional chefs alike invent new recipes all the time, sometimes competing in national pie competitions in an attempt to create a new favorite flavor. Nothing beats the classics, though. Here’s a closer look at the origins of five of the world's most popular pies.

Mincemeat Pie: Cuisine From the Crusades

A box stacked full of mince pies with a star shape on top
Credit: Magdanatka/ Shutterstock

In the 13th century, European crusaders returned home with stories of war — and, if legends are true, a few good pie recipes inspired by Middle Eastern cuisine, which fearlessly combined sweet and savory flavors. Clearly impressed, the crusaders told those back home about delicacies containing an array of meats, fruits, and spices available only in distant lands. (A 1390 recipe for “tartes of flesh,” for example, suggests adding saffron to a pastry of sugar, pork, cheese, and eggs.) Expensive to bake, the pie recipes influenced by the crusaders were initially  reserved for the wealthy or presented at feasts and holidays. By the 16th century, though, these “mincemeat” treats were a Christmastime mainstay. Today's mincemeat pies are actually just mince pies; meat was dropped from the recipe sometime before the Victorian era.

Blueberry Pie: A Wartime Treat

View from above of a blueberry pie
Credit: margouillatphotos/ iStock

Berry and drupe-based pies have existed since the 16th century, when Queen Elizabeth I famously took a bite of the world’s first cherry pie. But when pies came to the New World, non-native fruits took precedence over blueberries. That changed during the Civil War. As brother fought brother, sardine canneries in New England lost most of their business in the Deep South. Thankfully, Maine was (and is) the largest producer of wild blueberries in the world, so the factories pivoted to canning local fruits instead. Soon, the struggling canneries captured a new market: Soldiers who had never tasted Maine blueberries were downing the stuff by the dozens, transporting them in the form of pies. An American classic was born.

Apple Pie: Britain’s Gift to America

Close up of an apple pie
Credit: LauriPatterson/ iStock

The phrase “as American as apple pie” is a misnomer: The dish is decidedly British. Unlike blueberries, apple trees are not native to North America. (Rather, America’s first apple seeds and cuttings were brought over by Jamestown colonists for the purpose of making cider.) Britain’s first apple pie recipe was recorded back in 1381 by Canterbury Tales author Geoffrey Chaucer, who called for figs, berries, saffron, and more. Here it is:

Tak gode Applys and gode Spyeis and Figys and Reysons and Perys and wan they re wel ybrayed colourd wyth Safron wel and do yt in a cosyn and do yt forth to bake wel.

As with blueberry pie, America’s love affair with apple pie may be traced back to the United States military. By the early 20th century, America had become one of the world’s largest apple producers. During World War II, it was common for soldiers abroad to say they were fighting “for mom and apple pie.”

Pumpkin Pie: Star of America’s First Cookbook

A slice of pumpkin pie on a white plate
Credit: MargoeEdwards/ iStock

When you think of it, it’s odd to transform a gourd into a sweet dessert. But Americans have been doing it since the mid-17th century. In 1655 in New Netherland — now New York state — a Dutch lawyer named Adriaen van der Donck observed that “the English, who are fond of tasty food, like pumpkins very much and use them also in pies.” These early pastries, however, did not resemble modern pumpkin pies. “They contained layers of sliced (sometimes fried) pumpkin, combined with sugar, spices, and apple slices,” Ellen Terrell writes for the Library of Congress blog. The first modern custard-style pumpkin pie recipe wouldn’t be recorded until  141 years later, when Amelia Simmons wrote the first American cookbook. (You can view the recipe here.)

Key Lime Pie: The Pride of Florida

A slice of key lime pie with a bite missing and a blueberry on top
Credit: arianassphotography/ Unsplash

Floridians are defensive about their state pie — and for good reason. Key limes, with their uniquely pleasant pucker, are named for their association with the Florida Keys, where they first thrived in the United States. But the pie itself may not be a Sunshine State creation. According to some sources, the dairy-loving masterminds at the Borden Company concocted the recipe that would become key lime pie in a New York City test kitchen in 1931. (The recipe was a ploy to sell sweetened condensed milk.) Floridians, however, still insist that the original key lime pie was invented by a cook with the mysterious name of “Aunt Sally,” who allegedly adapted the recipe after acquiring it from sponge fisherman working off the Florida Keys.

You Might Be Interested In